उत्तरं यत्समुद्रस्य हिमाद्रेश्चैव दक्षिणम् ।
वर्षं तद् भारतं नाम भारती यत्र संततिः ।।
Uttaraṃ yatsamudrasya himādreścaiva dakṣiṇam
varṣaṃ tadbhārataṃ nāma bhāratī yatra santatiḥ (Vishnu Puranam II.3.1) Sri Parashar to Maitreya
Bhāratam, as clearly described above, is a word derived from Samskritam (Sanskrit) root bhŗ that means to bear/to carry. An interesting choice of word. What does it bear or carry? Is it:
- diversity and appreciation of thoughts and views?
- diversity and freedom of choices in worshiping (or lack of) gods and goddesses?
- Freedom to reject forms of gods and goddesses and yet practice the culture
- diversity in culture and arts?
- diversity of values and belief systems?
- diversity of gender and people?
- diversity of occupation?
- diversity of languages (over 1600 languages)
- diversity in sampradāya and spiritual paths?
- respect for that diversity?
- diversity in different schools of thought and wisdom co-existing peacefully?
- diverse environment?
- the list goes on and on....
The answer is, yes, perhaps all of the above and beyond. Despite these diversities, have you ever wondered how is it that while Europe struggles to maintain unity that India copes well with such diversity? Europe has around 200 languages with largely all of the the same religion, yet, the concept of European Union is complicated without unity.
India, on the other hand, does not struggle with this unity even though we have substantial and complicated forms of diversity. We say there is unity in diversity in India. What is the unique entity of unity in India? It cannot be religion, evidence from Europe suggests religion could not bind them together. Then what is it?
This unique element is what we call DHARMA. Dharma is most certainly NOT to be defined as religion as it is commonly used. Dharma is above and beyond that.
Dharma, a Sanskrit word, the root being dhŗ
(to hold/sustain) – ‘dhriyate anena iti’ - that by which (it is) held/upheld, supported, sustained/nourished. The principle of holding together a society so as to be interoperable with all the elements of diversities mentioned above, yet, very effectively describing duties and responsibilities of citizens recognising individual freedom, rights and equality is called DHARMA.
It is this Dharma, that binds followers of Sanātana Dharma from Kashmir (sadly only a few thousands remain now) to Kanyakumaari and from Arunachal Pradesh to Kutch. It is the fabric of Dharma that unites Indians. It is this foundation that is the inner architecture of India and Indians. It is this composition that is the ātma of India! Our identity is Dharma. Once this remarkable and noteworthy identity of Dharma is damaged, the unity is damaged.
Do you see now why the word bhāratam was chosen? Bhāratam holds that Dharma, the Dharma, that holds the society together! The choice of the name for the region indicates the depth of that civilisation. The civilisation of Dharma, let's call it the Indic civilisation.
Note: Highlighting here that abrahamic cultures (Christianity & Islam) were not built from the perspective of society. Their basis is on an establishment of god and religion, and so, they have struggled with unity. Dharma is a extraordinary concept that differentiates between cultures that have origins outside India from the ones that originated within India (Hinduism, Buddhism, Sikhs and Jainism). Hindus, Jains, Sikhs and Buddhist, even though they are of different religions, have co-existed peacefully because Dharma's innate teaching is diversity. A Hindu has no problem in co-existing with one following Jainism or Sikhism or Buddhism and the same applies to a Sikh, Jain or Buddhist, they have no problem in co-existing with a Hindu. Therefore, a Hindu has no problem in co-existing with any other culture or religion in the world (Christianity and Islam) - Indians welcomed them. All forms of thoughts originating in India give prime importance to Dharma (Ethical, Legal, Moral and Social goals of a human and society) and it forms the basis of all narratives, arguments and perspectives in all forms of multi-cultural forums, politics, law and its execution, media, academia, arts, history, education, etc.
This phenomenal principle being the identity of India must be recognised, appreciated and protected for its uniqueness being indigenous to India! If Dharma is the principle then Dhārmika is its product or the individual. While, a revisit to Dharma and Dhārmika is necessary, first however, it is necessary to understand identity and its importance.
Why is identity an important topic?
- Name is identity
- Gender is identity
- Age group is a form of identity
- Family, village, town, city and state are identities
- Language is an identity and it is politicised
- Ethnic origin is identity
- Even on acquiring foreign citizenship, the ethnicity remains, therefore identity of the individual remains
- Generation is an identity
- Religion (or lack of) is identity
- Left-wing activists operate on identity!
- Reservations in India are based on identity
- Government initiatives for minorities based on identity, to name a few:
- Prime Minister’s New 15 Point Program for the Welfare of Minorities is an identity initiative (http://minorityaffairs.gov.in/sites/default/files/amended_guidelines.pdf)
- The Andhra Pradesh State Christian (Minorities) Finance Corporation is based on identity
- Haj subsidy is based on identity
- Kerala State Development Corporation for Christian Converts from Scheduled Castes and the Recommended Communities is based on identity
- Maulana Azad Education Foundation is based on identity
- Maulana Azad Minorities Financial Development Corporation Limited is based on identity
- Ministry of Minority Affairs is based on identity
- Morarji Desai Residential Schools for Minorities is based on identity
- National Commission for Minorities is based on identity
- National Commission for Minority Educational Institutions is based on identity
- National Commission for Religious and Linguistic Minorities is based on identity
- National Minorities Development and Finance Corporation is based on identity
- Sachar Committee is based on identity
- Shaadi Bhagya scheme is based on identity
- Telangana Minority Residential Education is based on identity
- In Tamil Nadu, Dravidian politics are based on identity
- Dalit issues are based on identity
- Women rights are based on identity
- Transgender rights are based on identity
The point I am trying to impress upon the reader is that 'identity' is at the epicentre of your daily life.
Identity is at the core of dialogue, politics, media, and debate. Based on this trend, identity politics will continue to dominate in shaping the future of world. Anyone who says identity is not important is attempting to fool the other. Therefore:
- does it not become pertinent to know one's own identity given that it affects everyone everyday?
- where does a Dhārmika fit in this identity conundrum?
- or does a Dhārmika's identity not matter since they generally accept a position of apathy?
If the unique identity of Dharma and Dhārmika (as groups and as individuals) are to be valued today and into the future, then, every Dhārmika MUST STAND UP as individual and as united groups to protect and to progress Dharma. To be successful at this, every Dhārmika must be educated sufficiently in Dharma to logically present arguments in discussions.
While left-wing, political, media and other forces in India are pumping and boosting identity empowerment of non-Dharmic cultures (largely religious minorities, notwithstanding, articles 29 and 30 of the Indian constitution does not limit 'minorities' to religion. What that means is - a Gujarati-speaking community in Tamil Nadu, according to Article 29 and 30, can claim minority status in that state based on language - this discussion is for another day), while the individuals in the Indic are apathetic to this.
While this identity of the Dhārmika is being targeted with a continuous pressure to alienate the Dhārmika from her/his heritage, s/he does not even recognise that there are forces attempting to remove the innate identity and replace it with another. At the very first stage, as opportunity is grasped or created. One of the ways is planting a sense of embarrassment and guilt in the mind of the Dhārmika and building narratives to the level that the Dharma principle is ejected from its representative. This creates an identity vacuum which is the next stage. Finally, re-program the ex-Dhārmika (having created a vacuum from the previous state) to progress their (external forces) narratives and agenda. Once the product (Dhārmika) is affected, its principle, Dharma is also affected eventually leading to cultural suicide.
As it can be appreciated by now that identity shapes national laws, policies and initiatives, should not the Dhārmika have a say in shaping the future of India?
The Indic (Dhārmika) have been progressively attacked and marginalised due to Islamic invasions and European colonisation characterised by bloodshed, the Islamisation and Europeanisation of the education system, selective minority (religious) politics since independence, to name a few. I am yet to read an history school book published in India which speaks the truth about Hindu, Buddhist, Sikh and Jain massacres occurred during the Islamic period. A form of deception so to speak, to not reveal the truth as a result of invasions and the audacity to project the invaders to the extent of freedom fighters could account to all forms of morality, however, this comes down to who in India has control over the education departments. Point worthy to note here is the projection of false narrative (more on this later).
The Dhārmika continues to sleep while Dharma is being deteriorated in front of her/his eyes. The principle (Dharma) cannot stand up for itself, it is the Dhārmika (principle's representative) who must WAKE UP to this and protect the principle!
This is one of the concepts explained through the Bhagavad Gita. Lord Krishna instructs Arjuna (the Dhārmika) on why he must stand up for Dharma. Despite having instructed on Bhakti, Gyana and Moksha, Lord Krishna did NOT instruct Arjuna to drop his weapons and travel into the forest to perform Bhakti (loving devotion), yagya or puja (rituals) on a form of deity. The reasons were also NOT to establish sampradaaya, or a form of religion or a form of deity worship. It was solely for the purpose of establishing DHARMA in the society did Lord Krishna instruct Arjuna to perform the rightful and skillful action. This is a critical point worthy of
noting again unique to Bhārat. Where we note in the Christian and
Islamic context that a God is central theme, the central theme for the Indic civilisation is Dharma (Moral, legal, ethical and social duties and responsibilities coupled with individual freedom and liberty)! Is this Dharma not worthy of
protection (samrakshanam)?
The fight in our sense is not in a battlefield but with forces attempting to change the history of the Indic civilisation in the areas of politics, arts, history, academia, science, culture, national policies, law, courts, even medicine, to name a few.
It is critical that the current living Indics take interest and represent Dharma as true Dhārmika in the above fields in order to stand up and defend the views of Dharma when other forces interpret it without a basis, to therefore protect and foster Dharma for the future generations (regardless of ethnic background, religion/culture, nationality, sexual orientation, gender etc) - whoever loves the culture.
Only a collective Indic force can protect and sustain Dharma for generations to come. I endeavor to take you through this journey from personal identity (Dhārmika) to Dharma in its current state. Although, I may fail miserably in this prospect, nevertheless, I attempt as my duty towards this Dharma....
to be continued.....
Dharma - The Indian identity
It really good...what are all the means to fight against these adharmas in Kali Yuga? Surely not through swords or arrows or modern weapons of war...a systematic revolution underlining the need for protecting dharma through non- violence means may help
ReplyDeleteNamaste Abhishek,
ReplyDeleteGlad to see the blog! The way you were narrowing it down from a larger perspective was impressive. It is doubly impressive that despite you being far away from our holy land, your heart still beats for this country.
The blog's language is free flowing and highly accurate. Keep it up. Let this continue forever.
Indic ethos are relevant beyond time..means and methods to educate these ethos among all communities of Hindus may be tough initially but a sustained efforts over a period of time may see the results at the end..it is a continuous process of sensitising the Hindus to uphold their Dharma at any cost..Indic concepts will never fade for sure...
ReplyDeleteRespected Abhishek Swamy, you have been quite startling at the starting itself, in arriving at the root of the name of our land, Bharatha. It's furthermore amazing and enthusing that you have gone straight into the core of the meaning of the Dharma. You have convincingly deduced that it's because of this unique oneness in their roots both Bharatha and Dharma are organically blended. Sri Aurobindo has a similar view. He also holds that the asthma if Bharatha is Dharma. Further your relevance has to be appreciated when you firmly, but politely, suggested that Dharma does not get exhausted in any of the rigid-looking dharmic activities. It's all- encompassing and even beyond, as you have rightly observed. Sanathana Dharma is all against bigotry and dogma. It accepts any thought but in it's own way. I am more than happy to see that the cat is out at last. In your coming blogs, Please dwell upon the need and the method of reinterpreting our ever- renewable ancient customs, of course, without ruining the essential portions. That will bring many young thinking individuals to the task of "Taking care if Dharma, for, then it would take care of us". धर्मो रक्षति रक्षितः।.Please continue with the requisite zest and zeal. भगवदनुग्रह प्राप्तिरस्तु।.
ReplyDeleteThe above observation was from D. Srinivasan, Bangalore.
ReplyDeleteD.Srinivasan. Further more your reference to the concept identity as essential to Dharma is very apt, because in sanathanadharma individual is held as uniquely supreme and even the flood of universality cannot crush it. Also the world here and now is never looked upon as opposed to the other world beyond. That is the reason Dharma is the key for happiness here as well as beyond.
ReplyDeleteVery good topic neatly projected. The main essence what I perceive, is coming from the heart of person, indicating the dedication. May GOD Bless you
ReplyDeleteQuite exhaustive and informative. Stay blessed and continue to share more such information.
ReplyDeleteExplained well. Thanks. Hope it reaches the mass as this is the need of the hour now. Dharma and identity were always linked to one another and there was no need to consciously show since it was our very way of life till a few decades back.
ReplyDeleteVery precisely and clearly presented. Easy to relate and understand for anyone who wants to know more about our dharmik culture. Very clear explanation on how it’s been explained and deduced to show its significance over others and the reason it’s sustained till date. Looking forward for more such topics.
ReplyDeleteReally great explanation of our Dhrma which can be understand by every one why by all other religion in the worldwide. God blessing is always for him and expecting for more such topics. Good luck
ReplyDeleteIn a lighter vein, my identity is I am the servant of Lord Narayan. He is the owner of my soul. He commands my every action giving weight to my past and present Karma. He has made me to understand this. Not withstanding adiyen’s outward appearance, sorrow, joys, mistakes, good deeds, I am the happiest soul having surrendered to Him. Sri Abhishek. Your presentation is superb. This perhaps a beginning of many more similar future soul-searching presentations from you.
ReplyDeleteFully agree with you and join you in this noble cause.
ReplyDeleteAbhishek Swamy
ReplyDeleteExtremely well-written blog. Even a novice such as Adiyen is able to relate to the narration and understand that it is the foundation of Dharma on which the edifice of Bharatam stands and that it is Dharma that has help sustain our land, culture and community whenever foreign invasions have threatened to disturb the rubric of this fabric. Adiyen is able to grasp the true import of the verse
धर्म एव हतो हन्ति धर्मो रक्षति रक्षितः ।
तस्माद् धर्मो न हन्तव्यो मा नो धर्मो हतोऽवधीत् || (Manusmriti 8.15). Adiyen shall try to stand up for the cause यथा शक्ति।
दासन्।
Adiyen🙏. You have very beautifully highlighted the fact that the origin of most of our societal maladies is due to lack of Swaroopa Jnaanam.Once we are aware of our true nature and our association with the Supreme then following Dharma or walking in the Dharmic way will come to us effortlessly...you have done a beautiful root cause analysis and arrived at identity crisis as the problem.
ReplyDeleteMay the ever merciful Piratti and Perumal bless you and keep the flag of your brilliant kainkaryam flying high
Hare Krishna, very well thought and written analysis, As rightly said, only in this land tolerance towards other IDs are more conspicuous.
ReplyDeleteInteresting article. I was directed to your blog by your colleague M Ayyar . Maybe we could meet one day and have a chat . My thinking is in the same wavelength as yours.
ReplyDeleteDr Rama Krishnan
Thank you. Please email me at sydneyvaidikam@gmail.com
Delete